Loading...
Compare Claude vs Amazon Q Developer vs Gemini Code for AWS cloud development. Real benchmarks, pricing analysis, and production use cases for selection.
Comprehensive comparison of Claude Code, Amazon Q Developer (formerly CodeWhisperer), and Google Gemini Code Assist for cloud development. We analyzed platform integration, AWS features, pricing, and real performance metrics to help you choose the best AI coding assistant for your cloud infrastructure needs.
| Feature | Amazon Q Developer | Gemini Code Assist | Claude Code | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AWS Service Support | 250+ services native | Basic AWS patterns | Comprehensive via Bedrock | |
| Code Quality Score | 37% acceptance rate | 63.2% SWE-bench | 72.7% SWE-bench | |
| Monthly Cost | $19 Pro tier | $19 Standard | $40-200 varies | |
| Multi-Cloud Support | AWS-focused only | GCP-optimized primarily | All major clouds |
Comprehensive analysis of each platform's capabilities
Amazon Q Developer (formerly CodeWhisperer) provides deep AWS integration across 250+ services. Released in 2022, it focuses on AWS-native development with enterprise security features.
Generate complete serverless functions with automatic event handlers and IAM policies
Built-in OWASP Top 10 vulnerability detection with one-click remediation
Generate production-ready templates with proper dependencies and parameters
Multi-cloud support: Limited capabilities outside AWS ecosystem
Transformation limits: 4,000 lines monthly shared across organization at Pro tier
Response quality: 37% code acceptance rate lower than competitors
Free Tier: 50 monthly requests with basic features
Professional: $19/month unlimited requests plus security scanning
Enterprise: Custom pricing with IP indemnification and SSO
AWS-centric teams building serverless applications, requiring native service integration. Ideal for organizations prioritizing security scanning and compliance.
Google Gemini Code Assist offers a 1-million token context window with strong GCP integration. Launched in 2024, it specializes in Kubernetes and container orchestration.
180,000 monthly completions free versus 50 for competitors
1 million tokens enables understanding entire cloud architectures
Deep BigQuery, Cloud Functions, and Cloud Run support
Performance delays: Users report 10+ second response times for complex queries
AWS support: Lacks understanding of AWS-specific patterns and optimizations
Enterprise features: Code customization requires expensive Enterprise tier at $45/month
Free Option: 180,000 completions monthly with 6,000 daily limit
Standard Plans: $19/month for unlimited completions
Enterprise: $45/month includes code customization and VPC controls
Google Cloud users, cost-conscious teams, and Kubernetes-heavy deployments. Perfect for startups maximizing free tier value.
Claude Code delivers superior code quality with multi-cloud flexibility and agentic capabilities. Available through terminal-first interface with 200,000-token context.
72.7% SWE-bench accuracy, highest among all platforms tested
Platform-agnostic design supporting AWS, GCP, and Azure equally
Superior architectural understanding for complex distributed systems
Premium pricing: $40-200 monthly significantly exceeds competitor pricing
Terminal-only: CLI interface may alienate GUI-preferring developers
Security scanning: Requires third-party tool integration unlike native competitors
Professional: $40/month for individual developers
Team Plans: $60/month per user (excludes Claude Code access)
Enterprise: $200/month with advanced features and support
Multi-cloud architectures, complex system design, and teams prioritizing code quality. Some enterprises report significant cost savings.
| Feature | Amazon Q Developer | Gemini Code Assist | Claude Code | Test Method |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SWE-bench Accuracy | Not published | 63.2% | 72.7% | |
| Response Latency | <100ms inline | 10+ seconds complex | 2-5 seconds average | |
| Code Acceptance | 37% at BT Group | Not published | 72% at TELUS |
Which tool performs best for specific scenarios
Scenario: Building serverless APIs with DynamoDB, S3, and EventBridge integration
Winner: Amazon Q Developer - Native AWS integration provides unmatched serverless development efficiency
"Claude Code has helped us generate numerous internal AI tools. The platform has reduced our software release times while maintaining code quality."
Decision criteria to help select the right tool
AWS-only infrastructure • Need security scanning • Budget under $20/month • Serverless focus
Google Cloud primary • Cost-sensitive team • Need 180K free completions • Kubernetes heavy
Multi-cloud architecture • Code quality priority • Complex systems • Budget flexibility
Hybrid cloud strategy • Mixed skill levels • Varying project complexity • Department autonomy
| Feature | Amazon Q Developer | Gemini Code Assist | Claude Code |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base Subscription | $228 ($19×12) | $228 ($19×12) | $480-2400 varies |
| Usage Overages | None with Pro | None Standard | Token-based extra |
| Security Scanning | Included Pro | $540 (external) | $600 (third-party) |
| Training/Onboarding | $500 estimated | $300 simple | $1000 advanced |
| **Total First Year** | **$728** | **$1068** | **$2080-4000** |
Based on comprehensive analysis comparing Claude Code, Amazon Q Developer, and Google Gemini Code Assist, our recommendation for AWS-focused teams is Amazon Q Developer. This choice provides native AWS integration, built-in security scanning, and reasonable pricing while addressing cloud development requirements effectively.
Answers to frequently asked questions about choosing between these tools
Detailed comparison of Claude and Copilot for Python projects
guideCompare top AI coding assistants for general development
guideGuide to building production-ready serverless applications
tutorialLoading reviews...